Imagine the new Lamborghini Gallardo SE without
a transmission. The automobile's capability to
go from 0 to 100 kilometers per hour (62 mph)
in 3.95 seconds or hit its top speed of 315 kilometers
per hour (193 mph) are meaningless without the
mechanism that transmits the power from the engine
to the driving axle. Without the transmission,
the car would be nothing more than an artistic
piece of metal and fiberglass.
The same is true of the golf club. No matter
how much technology is packed into a 460cc driver
clubhead, incredibly designed hybrid clubhead
or forged ironhead, without the shaft there's
little to talk about. Like a transmission, the
shaft is the device that transfers the power generated
by the engine (the golfer) to the driving axle
(the clubhead).
Golfers who consider shaft technology and investigate
which golf club "transmission" best fits their
swing and physical capabilities can increase on-course
performance.
Shaft technology continues to evolve at a frenetic
pace. More focus by original equipment manufacturers
(OEMs) on shaft design and providing consumers
with custom shaft choices, the incorporation of
nano technology into composite shafts, new alloys
in the steel segment, shafts made specifically
for hybrid clubs, and counter-balanced shafts
for putters are all significant trends and recent
innovations.
The potential of the shaft is most evident in
the driver segment, where clubhead design continues
to be limited by the United States Golf Association
(USGA). For now, the limits have thrown club designers
a curve ball. Engineering gurus are working hard
to find ways to significantly enhance or alter
clubhead playability while conforming to USGA
parameters. Consequently, many hopes for driver
playability improvement fall on the shaft.
This doesn't mean new iron shafts aren't better
than ever or offering tremendous playability benefit.
They are. The gap between steel and graphite shaft
weights and performance continues to narrow. Steel
alloys are allowing manufacturers to make lighter
steel shafts for more graphite-like performance
(distance increases), while composite iron shaft
tolerances are much tighter, allowing for more
steel-like accuracy and dependability.
"The evolution of shaft materials, designs, processes
and technologies continues to allow us to provide
golfers enhanced performance from their golf clubs,"
says Todd Cassidy, vice president of AccuFlex.
"A better shaft can make a golf club work better,
and different shafts offer different playability
characteristics. When the exact same clubhead
and grip combination are fit with five different
shafts, different performance characteristics
are produced by each club. That means there are
more options for golfers of all skill levels,
so every player can get what he needs."
Wide-ranging shaft performance capabilities have
resulted in a much-needed offering from OEMs --
custom shaft upgrades. Only a few years ago, just
a handful of OEMs offered shaft upgrades. Now,
every major golf manufacturer offers upgrade/custom
options.
"Golfers and OEMs are more focused on the shaft
than ever before," explains Robb Schikner, vice
president of research and development for Graphite
Design International. "OEMs have upgraded the
stock shafts they put into their product and are
offering custom upgrade shafts that add both value
and performance to their product. I think we will
see an even wider selection of shaft offerings
in the future. Golf swings are so varied in speed,
tempo, release point, etc., that it's very difficult
to fit every customer with the standard flex offerings
of A, R, S and X."
With stock shafts, OEMs must hit a certain retail
price point. That hampers the manufacturer's ability
to use high-end shafts in their off-the-rack clubs.
In shafts, price is generally indicative of quality.
The higher a designer can go on shaft costs, the
more materials and processes there are available
to lower torque, bring shaft weight down and enhance
other performance characteristics.
In addition, stock shafts must perform for wide
player segments based on flex, while most high-end
shafts fit specific categories or players. They
simply are not appropriate in a stock club regardless
of cost. This doesn't mean stock shafts don't
perform. They perform well for a wide range of
players, and they're better than ever.
"Upgrade shaft options simply allow golfers to
fine tune their clubs to achieve peak performance
from the shaft and the golf club by matching the
shaft to swing characteristics and thus optimize
launch conditions," explains Chad Hall, director
of marketing for True Temper Sports, the world's
largest shaft manufacturer.
"Without a properly fit shaft, it doesn't matter
what clubhead you have," adds Chris Elson, vice
president of business development and tour relations
for Harrison Sports. "The club isn't going to
work for you. The shaft must fit the clubhead
design and the player to achieve optimum performance."
The only pitfall of all the shaft technology
and design offerings is consumer confusion. Selecting
the right shaft for a particular clubhead that
also matches the player's swing characteristics
isn't a simple task.
Hall acknowledges that many golfers are so overwhelmed
by the shaft options available that they're actually
reluctant to jump in and try to find the shaft
that performs best for them with their woods and
irons, and for good reason.
The odds of finding the right shaft by thumbing
through the vast selection in the Golfsmith catalog
are slim. Golfers have two viable options -- utilize
upgrade offerings available from OEMs and/or work
with a professional fitter to get the right shaft.
"Most consumer confusion comes from the lack
of proper fitting," Schikner says. "Consumers
may try a shaft based on an advertisement or what
professional players use, but the best way to
make sure their shaft fits their swing is to go
to a reputable golf shop and try out different
products."
Hitting and comparing the performance of different
shafts are the keys to making the right selection.
Today, this is easier than ever. In the past several
years, OEMs have made clubs with the same clubhead
and their different custom shafts available to
consumers at the point of sale. At the shop or
through demo-day participation, anyone can test
one clubhead with different shafts. Comparing
different shafts with similar flex properties
allows the player to see which shaft provides
optimum ball flight, distance and feel.
What the professional clubfitter or high-end
golf retailer brings to the shaft-fitting mix
that may not be available during a demo day is
the chance to try various manufacturers' clubheads
and shaft options and to analyze each by using
a launch monitor.
"Launch monitors measure ball speed, launch angle
and spin rate, among other things," Hall notes.
"There's no standard combination of numbers in
regard to these elements that results in optimum
performance for all players. It varies from player
to player. So what players need to do is find
the combination of spin rate and launch angle
that maximizes ball speed with the clubhead they
choose to use. By reviewing the data measured
by a launch monitor, clubfitters can make solid
shaft recommendations."
Looking to the future, shaft manufacturers are
optimistic about the potential to continue improving
their products and bringing measurable playability
benefit to golfers of all skill levels.